Summary
- ATE insurance can cover adverse costs and the insured’s own costs if a case is unsuccessful.
- Set-off and reimbursement clauses prevent insured parties from recovering the same costs twice.
- Even a partial settlement or award may count as a successful outcome and trigger these clauses.
- Mixed outcomes can create complexity where policies cover multiple claims, claimants or defendants.
- Policy wording should be reviewed carefully, and recoveries may need to be held on trust.
After the Event (“ATE”) insurance is a critical component in the modern disputes ecosystem, protecting against adverse costs and own costs/disbursements if an Insured is unsuccessful with their case. It is also frequently used to assist with security for costs challenges, removing the need to submit monies in to court. A standard ATE policy includes several important clauses that affect how, when and in certain circumstances, if Insurers will pay out and what recourse they have to recover funds. Amongst the most overlooked are the set-off and reimbursement clauses. Here, we explore their application, the implications, and what considerations insured parties must give to those clauses when entering an ATE policy.
What are set-off and reimbursement clauses?
The practices of set-off and reimbursement within commercial contracts are well settled. In terms of insurance, and specifically ATE insurance, the guiding principle is that a “debtor” (the Insured party) should not be entitled to use another party’s (the Insurer’s) debt to pay its own liabilities. The clauses are therefore drafted to protect the Insurer’s financial interest and to prevent the Insured from unjust enrichment or double recoveries at the Insurer’s expense, which allows them to more effectively manage their financial risk, limit their exposure and therefore offer more competitive pricing for coverage.
From the perspective of the insured, set-off and reimbursement clauses can create outcomes that must be carefully considered when negotiating the policy prior to inception. When looking at a dispute and considering potential eventualities in terms of result, these outcomes, with respect to set-off and reimbursement, can become more nuanced if multiple respondents are being pursued by the Insured, multiple claimants are insured on one policy, or if there are multiple heads of claim in a set of proceedings.
The set-off and reimbursement clauses in an ATE insurance policy typically allow the insurer to:
- Set-off any amount due from the opponent(s) under the policy against any claim made under the policy; and/or
- Seek reimbursement from the insured in certain situations, usually where the insurer has made an interim claim under the policy, where the Insured ultimately recovers damages or costs that the Insurer is entitled to under the terms of the policy.
For the purpose of enforcing these clauses, ATE policies typically require sums recovered by the Insured during the dispute to be held on trust pending the final outcome.
To further explore how these clauses operate, and whilst the wordings can differ between policies, we set out an example below:
The insured agrees that in the event of a Successful Outcome the insured shall:
- reimburse the insurer in respect of any sums paid by the insurer under the terms of this policy to the extent that such sums can be met out of sums recovered from the opponent. For this purpose, the solicitor agrees to hold on trust all sums which the insured recovers from the opponent to the insurer’s order pending such reimbursement; and
- offset all sums due from the opponent against any claim made or that may be made under this policy.
Taking the example wording above, it is important to note that the implications of set-off and reimbursement clauses only become applicable in the event of a “Successful Outcome”. Again and whilst definitions can differ between policy wordings, the definition of Success broadly means:
- The recovery by the Insured at the final determination of the Dispute, of any sum of money or monetary equivalent from the Opponent regardless of any description which may be attributed to it by the Insured, the Opponent or anyone else.
Insureds often assume that success means winning the case in the conventional sense. In practice, standard policy definitions are much broader.
Under our example, a successful outcome arises where the Insured recovers any sum of money or monetary equivalent from the opponent at the conclusion of the dispute, irrespective of how that payment is characterised. Accordingly, a recovery achieved through settlement, a payment made without admission of liability, a negotiated compromise of costs, or a judgment in respect of only part of the claim may all be sufficient to engage the set-off and reimbursement clauses.
This is why the interaction between the definition of “Successful Outcome” and the set-off and reimbursement wording should be considered carefully. Where a dispute may produce a mixed or partial result, wording that explains how recoveries are to be applied against insured liabilities can be more helpful than wording which simply treats any recovery as success. Historically, this saw ATE policies treat such scenarios as a “win v one equals a win v all”, particularly where there were multiple opponents or multiple heads of claim. These outcomes were considered less equitable for insured parties and therefore insurers moved to the application of set-off and reimbursement clauses. However, whilst an improved position for insured parties, the potential outcomes still need to be carefully considered.
The practical operation of set-off and reimbursement clauses
Whilst set-off and reimbursement clauses appear relatively straightforward when viewed in isolation, their application can become more complex.
As per the example provided, insurers require the Insured, in the event of a successful outcome, to reimburse the Insurer for any sums paid under the policy out of sums recovered from the opponent and to set-off all sums recovered from the opponent against any claim due in respect of the insured liability.
Viewed from the insurer's perspective, these provisions ensure that the policy functions as an indemnity product rather than a mechanism by which an insured can be unjustly enriched by receiving a double payment. If costs, disbursements or liabilities indemnified by the insurer are subsequently recovered from an opponent, the insurer is entitled to be placed back in the position it would have been in had those sums been recovered directly from the opponent.
As touched upon, the position is relatively straightforward where there is a single claimant, a single defendant and a binary outcome of successful or unsuccessful. However, commercial disputes rarely follow such a straightforward pattern. Claims frequently involve multiple parties, multiple causes of action and mixed outcomes, all of which can create uncertainty regarding how recoveries should be allocated, liabilities set-off and how reimbursement provisions should operate.
In such circumstances, parties must look beyond simply the result of the litigation and carefully consider what has actually been recovered, against whom, and in relation to which part of a dispute.
Multiple claimants under a single policy
Particular issues can arise where a policy insures multiple claimants.
Whilst each claimant may have separate interests and separate claims, the policy wording will treat them collectively for the purposes of determining whether a successful outcome has been achieved and whether the insurer's set-off and reimbursement rights have been triggered. Problems may arise where one claimant obtains a substantial recovery whilst another claimant fails entirely.
The successful claimant may take the view that its recovery relates solely to its own successful cause of action and should not be diluted by liabilities attributable to another claimant. However, the Insurer will argue that where cover has been provided under a single policy, recoveries obtained by one Insured should be available to satisfy set-off and reimbursement obligations arising under the policy as a whole.
These competing positions can create significant tension at the conclusion of proceedings, particularly where recoveries are insufficient to meet all of the obligations under the policy, premium, costs etc.
For that reason, where multiple claimants are to be insured under a single ATE policy, consideration should be given at inception to whether recoveries and reimbursement obligations should operate collectively or on a claimant-by-claimant basis, the question should be asked, do all of the claimants claims rise and fall as one?
Multiple heads of claim
A similar issue arises where a claimant advances multiple causes of action or multiple heads of loss within the same set of proceedings.
Commercial disputes frequently involve claims for different, but perhaps, overlapping causes of action. Equally, a claimant may pursue several distinct heads of loss, some of which ultimately succeed whilst others are unsuccessful.
It is important to note that typically, ATE policies are not drafted by reference to individual causes of action if they are brought in one set of proceedings. Instead, they focus on whether there has been a successful outcome in the dispute as a whole.
The example we provide above defines a successful outcome broadly as the recovery by the Insured of any sum of money or monetary equivalent from the opponent at the conclusion of the dispute, regardless of the description attributed to that recovery.
As a result, even where a claimant fails on substantial parts of its claim, the recovery of damages, costs or another monetary benefit under a successful head of claim will trigger the set-off and reimbursement clauses.
At the conclusion of the dispute, even where a claimant has achieved some success, this can mean that they receive nothing by way of return should the insurer set-off liabilities that exceed the damages or costs awarded against the successful heads of claim. These are issues that are often overlooked when the policy is placed but become highly relevant when settlement negotiations commence or judgment is handed down.
Multiple defendants
The operation of set-off and reimbursement clauses can become particularly complex where claims are pursued against multiple defendants.
In commercial disputes it is common for claimants to pursue a combination of corporate entities, directors, professional advisers, intermediaries or other parties who are alleged to have contributed to the same loss.
It is entirely plausible and we often see a claimant succeed against some defendants whilst being unsuccessful against others. In those circumstances, a claimant may recover substantial damages and costs from one defendant whilst simultaneously becoming liable for the adverse costs of another defendant or defendants who have successfully defended the claim.
From the claimant's perspective, those outcomes are often viewed separately. However, from the perspective of the ATE policy, the existence of recoveries from one opponent will engage the Insurer's set-off and reimbursement rights. This can mean that liabilities to the successful opponents outweigh the recoveries made from others and the insurer would expect those recoveries to satisfy a claim first prior to indemnifying any additional losses.
The larger and more complex the litigation, the more important these considerations become. Where claims are being pursued against numerous defendants with differing levels of exposure, it is often prudent for Insureds to understand the potential operation of set-off and reimbursement clauses before proceedings are commenced, rather than waiting until recoveries begin to materialise.
Hold on trust
Given the inclusion of these clauses and how they can operate in the different scenarios as explained means that it is imperative that any monies received during the course of the dispute are held on trust only and until any set-off or reimbursement liabilities have been satisfied. Insurers will be unforgiving in circumstances where monies have been used and not held. Should a liability for adverse costs arise, the insurer will be within their rights to proceed on the basis that the money should have been available for set-off and reimbursement purposes. This could mean the Insured having to settle personally any outstanding liabilities that would otherwise have been covered by the monies held on trust.
Conclusion
Set-off and reimbursement clauses are among the most commercially significant provisions in any ATE policy. Whilst their purpose is straightforward, namely to prevent unjust enrichment and preserve the indemnity nature of the insurance, their application can become nuanced where litigation produces mixed outcomes.
The complications are particularly evident where a single policy covers multiple claimants, where a dispute involves several causes of action, or where proceedings are pursued against multiple defendants with differing outcomes. In each of those scenarios, a recovery may trigger set-off and reimbursement obligations that Insured parties must be aware of. Their practical impact can be significant, affecting the insured’s financial recovery post-dispute and exposing them to potential liability even after the insurer has paid out. Careful reading, negotiation, and compliance are essential to ensure that the clause does not create unexpected exposure for the Insured. It is therefore important to ensure you engage with a professional insurance broker prior to entering into an ATE insurance policy so these clauses, and others contained within policies, are properly explained.
