When a cyberattack causes physical damage: what will insurance actually cover?
The real question is not just what happened
Recent reports of a cyberattack affecting refrigeration systems across French supermarkets have highlighted a risk that many businesses still find surprising: a cyber incident can lead to spoiled stock, physical damage and operational disruption. (For more in-depth information on these attacks, see our Howden Re article here). The loss is still developing, but current estimates put it in the tens of millions, underlining the potentially significant real-world financial impact of a cyber event.
For risk managers, finance teams and boards, the most important issue is not the mechanics of the incident, but whether losses that look and feel like property damage, including stock loss, equipment damage and business interruption, are insured when the trigger is cyber.
That question matters because the answer is not always obvious. In many organisations, cyber and property programmes are bought separately, managed by different teams and subject to exclusions, sub-limits and definitions that may not have been designed with cyber-triggered physical loss in mind.
Is it a property damage loss or a cyber loss?
The answer may be both, or neither, depending on how the policy is written.
A traditional property policy is usually designed to respond to physical loss or damage caused by insured perils, and typically excludes losses arising from cyber attacks. A cyber policy is usually designed to respond to network security failure, data loss, business interruption and related cyber costs. Cyber-triggered physical damage sits between those two worlds, which creates a potential grey area.
If a cyber event causes refrigeration equipment to fail, stock to spoil or machinery to be damaged, the business may assume either its property or cyber insurance will respond. In practice, off-the-shelf products may not provide the protection expected.
Loss of stock and physical damage arising from a cyber trigger are often not covered under standard, off-the-shelf placements unless those exposures have been specifically considered and addressed.
This is why policy wording, trigger language and the interaction between cyber, property and business interruption cover are so important.
The cover is available, but it needs to be designed deliberately
The good news is that the market can provide protection for these kinds of losses. Cover for cyber-related physical damage, stock loss, business interruption and supply chain disruption is broadly available in the cyber insurance market, but it is not something businesses should assume they already have.
A broker who understands both cyber and physical operational risk can help identify where a standard policy may fall short and where tailored coverage can close the gap.
The key is understanding the risks and exposures before a loss occurs, including:
- Whether cyber-triggered stock deterioration or loss is covered
- Whether physical damage caused by a cyber event is included or excluded
- How business interruption is triggered and measured
- Whether suppliers, outsourced systems or managed service providers are contemplated
- How limits, waiting periods, deductibles and exclusions apply across cyber and property policies
Let's talk
Cyber incidents are increasingly capable of creating real-world losses. Insurance can cover those losses, but only if the programme has been structured to do so.
At Howden, we help organisations understand where cyber, property damage, stock loss, business interruption and supply chain exposures intersect. We review existing arrangements, identify potential gaps and help tailor coverage to reflect the realities of the business.
If your business relies on connected equipment, temperature-controlled stock, automated systems or operational technology, now is the time to ask whether your current insurance would respond when a cyber event causes physical loss.